Numbing Cream vs Alternative Pain-Relief Methods: What Works Best?

If you've ever had a tattoo, gotten ready for laser hair removal, or got ready for a waxing appointment, then I'm sure you've thought to yourself, "How bad is this going to hurt?" 

Pain can be a major obstacle when it comes to cosmetic and skin treatments. This is where pain-relief products and methods can help. 
 
Topical numbing cream is probably the most common go-to, but many people still feel they get significant relief from foundational methods like getting an ice pack, breathing techniques, and even herbal remedies. So which method works best? Let's get into it. 

How Does A Numbing Cream Work? 

Numbing creams are topical anaesthetics that typically contain lidocaine or similar active ingredients, which temporarily block nerve signals in the skin. When applied about 30–60 minutes before the procedure, these creams can significantly reduce pain/discomfort for hours. 

Here is why a tattoo cream is recommended: 

• Scientifically proven to reduce pain 

• Long-lasting relief (usually 1–4 hours, dependent on the product) 

• Easy to apply at home 

• Been used for tattoos, waxing, piercings, laser, etc. 

Popular Alternative Pain-Relief Methods 

While numbing creams are the most popular option, others decide against creams with chemicals or want to try natural methods.  

Here are the most common: 

1. Ice or Cold Packs

Applying ice before a procedure reduces the amount of nervous stimulation and reduces the amount of pain. 

• Pros: Easy to do, cheap, natural. 

• Cons: Temporary relief; potential vasoconstriction can affect tattooing/waxing (but generally a good option). 

2. Herbal or Natural Remedies

Some individuals use aloe vera, clove oil or menthol-based balms. 

• Pros: Natural remedies; easy to access 

• Cons: Limited scientific evidence; effects are mild when compared to numbing cream. 

3. Over-the-Counter Pain Relief (oral tablets)

Some use mild pain-relievers, like ibuprofen, before the procedure. 

• Pros: Decreases pain and reduces swelling. 

• Cons: Longer time to kick in; might cause bruising or blood thinning during a tattoo. 

Side-by-Side Comparison 

So, What Works Best? 

In most cases of tattoo, piercing, waxing or laser treatments, topical numbing cream will be the best option. It will provide longer-lasting and more predictable relief than natural or alternative remedies. 

With this said, other alternative methods like breathing techniques, distraction, and ice can serve as great supplements to topical numbing cream, especially for those looking to manage anxiety along with physical pain. 

Final Word 

Everyone has a different pain threshold. What totally helps one person might only take the edge off for another. The challenge is to find the right balance. 

For longer or more intense procedures, numbing cream provides the greatest and most consistent relief.  For shorter or less intense interventions, natural methods might be all you need. 

At Numbastay, we provide the safest and most reliable tattoo numbing cream. Formulated by experts, these creams are used by popular tattoo artists and trusted by brands across Australia and globally.